126 Comments
User's avatar
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
4d3fect's avatar

No chance he even touched one. Probably directed the intern to chuck it all in the shredder.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
The Ghost of Cal Griffith's avatar

The chief intern returns to Manfred's office where he's practicing putting. "It's been done, sir."

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
A Salty Scientist's avatar

Lol. I seriously doubt there would be any takers. They have a glut of outfielders. I bet both O’Neill and Carlson have real value. I would probably keep Carlson and hope he figures it out considering his prospect pedigree, but he may need a change of scenery.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
A Salty Scientist's avatar

I love Edman as a Chone Figgins-type super utility guy who plays every day. His stats are great in CF, but he's also at least average in the infield, and there are very few players that can be average or better across the diamond. He provides a ton of flexibility in the case of injuries too.

Expand full comment
Black Sable's avatar

Any chance they can trade Marmol for a bag of used baseballs? He handles a pitching staff like Mike Matheny used to.

Expand full comment
Wes's avatar

Marmol doesn't have anything to do with the atrocious blown saves...lack of hitting...and a complete fuckstick of a pitching staff (save Montgomery and recently Flaherty).

Expand full comment
Wes's avatar

I think O'Neill and possibly Carlson are gone. I also think their patience with DeJong has worn thin (although I don't know that I agree with trading him). I would be surprised if Goldy isn't traded. Just can't see them spending the kind of coin needed to resign him and he's 35 years old. Don't want Hicks to be traded but it wouldn't surprise me. I would love for them to resign Montgomery. All of these things should be taken with a huge grain of salt as I typically don't know my ass from a hole in the ground.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Wes's avatar

I hope you are right. From my pessimistic view it would be the cherry on top to blow everything up and start over. Just trade some OF'ers and pick up some fucking pitchers already!

Expand full comment
Ryan Fiala's avatar

DeJong also graduated with a Biology degree from THE Illinois State University. That should make the option pick-up a no-brainer. He’s probably already helping the pitching staff with sticky substance workarounds.

Expand full comment
Wes's avatar

Biology and pre med. He could also assist the team Doctor. Triple threat!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
DMCj's avatar

Doughmo arigato, Mr. Breadboto…

Expand full comment
dlf's avatar

I kneaded that comment.

Expand full comment
DMCj's avatar

I'm glad. It came from a place of loaf.

Expand full comment
JimP's avatar

It's just your rye sense of humor and dry wheat.

Expand full comment
DMCj's avatar

Thanks for the challah back.

Expand full comment
dlf's avatar

You’re trying to get a rise out of me!

Expand full comment
Ferg's avatar

I’m crusty that you guys didn’t wait for me to rise. I deserve butter, but I’m not jelly and certainly don’t want to come across as kneady. Oh well, gotta roll.

Expand full comment
bachscore's avatar

#FutureYankee Jordan Montgomery

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
danceswvowels's avatar

Obviously Baez was a fine pickup for the moment but I remember cringing when they sent PCA over to the Cubs. Moreso than when they traded Kelenic to Seattle.

Expand full comment
Simon DelMonte's avatar

I wonder if there is any way the Mets could put together a package to get him. Probably not, but he is the sort of pitcher they could use going forward.

Expand full comment
bachscore's avatar

true.

Expand full comment
Simon DelMonte's avatar

I have zero issue with advertising patches, especially inobtrusive ones. (A lot better than the full uniform ads on EPL kits). But the advertiser in the Bronx is just weird. Starr Insurance doesn't do business with the public, only other businesses. This is therefore some effort to burnish the brand and to be connected with the Yankees. $20 million just to do that seems like a lot of money for little return. But what do I know? I don't have that kind of money.

Expand full comment
dlf's avatar

At least it sorta blends in. The ATL one is bright yellow. Maybe it could have looked okay on Kent Tekulve or Nate Colbert in 1978 but not on mid 20s Braves’ uniforms.

Expand full comment
Simon DelMonte's avatar

The Mets' ad patch was in red and white - the usual colors for advertiser New York-Presbyterian (hospitals) - but fans complained it was Phillies color, so it's now orange and blue. I assume that all Coca-Cola signage at Citi has also been changed. (I don't entirely love that a non-profit health care concern is spending its money that way, but at least I can say that it makes sense for them to advertise on the Mets jerseys when the hospital most likely to get patients in need of care at the ballpark is NYP Queens. And it's a pretty good hospital too.)

Expand full comment
danceswvowels's avatar

I'm still surprised at the Mets going that route because they have a coupon for a free sandwich after 100 visits to Hospital for Special Surgery.

Expand full comment
Richard S's avatar

As I understand it, "presbyterian" derives from a term meaning "old person", so it's appropriate for the Mets.....

Expand full comment
Simon DelMonte's avatar

The money NYP is giving the Mets pays for the special surgeries. Also, since other teams use HSS, it pays to have a backup option in case all the surgeons are repairing Knicks knees.

Expand full comment
rwlmo's avatar

It would be awesome if either the Marlins or the Rays would select Farmer’s Insurance as an advertising partner.

Expand full comment
bachscore's avatar

prob it's me, but I can't figure out how to renew early with the discount. is it new subs only? thanks

Expand full comment
NB3131's avatar

Pretty sure it’s new subs..

Expand full comment
Sean's avatar

Don’t think it is, because Craig included a little primer last week on how to change your existing subscription from monthly to annual.

Craig, if you’re out there, how much is the discounted subscription, so we can be sure we’re seeing the right thing if we try to switch?

Expand full comment
Craig Calcaterra's avatar

I've had a few people tell me that while Substack will let existing subscribers upgrade from monthly to annual, in some cases it has not given the sale pricing.

If you wish to do this and this happens to you, email me (reply to a newsletter; it goes just to me), and I will make sure you are credited the $14 or whatever the difference is.

Expand full comment
bachscore's avatar

sounds good, but I don't even see how to renew. I think I just have autorenew in August.

Expand full comment
bachscore's avatar

nah, everybody in the U.S. *already* subscribes, no?

Expand full comment
DMCj's avatar

Full disclosure: I am too chicken to play Immaculate Grid because I am terrible at paying attention to the details of, let alone remembering some guys. Which is weird because I’m usually good at trivia and I love baseball but for some reason the Grid leaves me lost. I enjoy looking at other peoples’ grids and marveling at what they know!

PS Drag him, Mayor Thao.

PPS The Rays’ Yandy Diaz got to Seattle at 230am the day of the ASG, hit a HR, and then flew back to Tampa in time to be with his wife when their son was born. Anyone else on the Rays who comes back from the break complaining that they are still tired should be ashamed of themselves.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
JasonG's avatar

Between the ages of 8-12, in my baseball-obsessed, card-collecting days, I probably would have been great at this game but now in middle age, I'd have no shot.

Expand full comment
DMCj's avatar

I was just thinking about baseball cards. I would have been able to tell you the quirky stories on the back (and maybe even describe the cartoon) but be completely lost on the stats.

Expand full comment
JasonG's avatar

Totally with ya there!

Expand full comment
aboutamoo's avatar

I didn't spend enough years collecting and obsessing over baseball cards, unfortunately. Topps '78 and '79 was pretty much it, and my "collections" were far from complete.

Expand full comment
A Salty Scientist's avatar

Same. I was able to come up with the 500 HR hitters quickly, and then stalled quickly. Got one dude that was notably traded, and then guessed one dude who played for *everyone*

Expand full comment
Sam Bass's avatar

It's funny how the structure of a trivia question can affect how well you can answer it. I can zip through a Sporcle quiz naming, say, all the 500 HR hitters -- but give me the first letter of their last name and I start staring blankly at the screen maybe 2/3 of the way through.

I also have selective team blindness....despite rooting for an NL East team, I struggle with Mets quizzes. A minute or so in, I'm like, I don't know...Mike Jorgensen??

Expand full comment
DMCj's avatar

Yeah - and I followed baseball but not closely during much of the 34 years between home teams in DC. Most of it, though, is that I treat MLB as an experience, remembering stories more than numbers. (Yandy Diaz is an excellent example. I have no idea how many home runs he has hit this year, or if he came to the Rays from another team - but I will likely always remember his eventful 2023 All-Star break.) But we have already established that I’m weird.

Expand full comment
aboutamoo's avatar

I've discovered, in a couple weeks of playing Immaculate Grid, that the 90s are a terrific blind spot for me. The four expansion teams in particular may as well not exist in my mind. But also, the players and teams they played for are just forgotten. I can remember the Griffeys and the Frank Thomases, but after that, there's a lot of blur. Which totally tracks, since my college and immediate post-college years were very... blurry.

On the plus side, Gaylord Perry has been like a personal cheat code on more than one occasion for me.

Expand full comment
rwlmo's avatar

What do you do if you can’t think of an answer?

Expand full comment
aboutamoo's avatar

First, I'll usually close the tab for a while and come back later. Occasionally, an answer will just jump out at me when I look again a couple hours later.

Another strategy, if one of the teams is the A's, Yankees, Blue Jays, Padres, or Red Sox, I will ask myself, "Did Rickey Henderson ever play for (the team in the other axis)?" Because sometimes the answer is yes.

Finally, I'll just think of catchers and relief pitchers from when I was a kid. If I can come up with one who definitely played for one of the teams, and I know he was a guy who bounced around a lot, I'll just guess.

Regardless, I always use all nine guesses, because you can't see the answers and the day's most popular responses until you do.

Expand full comment
rwlmo's avatar

I played today’s game and, as I expected, did horribly. Only three correct answers and two of them were obvious choices.

Expand full comment
Greg P's avatar

I got 6 today and was amazed that I pulled Mike Ivie out of my ass (0.2%)!

Expand full comment
pasta's avatar

I'm blown away by how good some people are at the Immaculate Grid. I'm sure some of them are cheating, but I believe there are people out there who are legitimately scoring 24 with answers like Octavio Dotel & Yorvit Torrealba. My proudest day was my 0.3% pull for an Orioles All Star (my boy George Sherrill), but I'm normally terrible at it. I think my best score is 5/9.

Expand full comment
Ferg's avatar

Nice! I pulled out Glenn Davis and got like a .9% one day last week. But overall, I’m terrible at remembering who played for two specific teams, I just can’t pull the data on even obvious ones like in Craig’s example above where he had Randy Johnson for Arizona and Seattle.

Expand full comment
aboutamoo's avatar

I think I got a 0.1% once. I want to say it was Ben Oglivie for the Brewers and Red Sox, but it might've been something else.

Expand full comment
ThisIsRuss's avatar

Here's how I play immaculate grid which could very well qualify as "Cheating" but, good news, I don't care: I think of a possible answer, then hit baseball-reference to see if it's correct. If not then I just learned something new about a player I hadn't thought of in a while and I move on. This method prevents me from putting in wrong answers but if I can't come up with the right one it just stays blank all day.

Expand full comment
Laura H Peebles's avatar

Baseball Reference smiles broadly.

Expand full comment
Stephanie D's avatar

Every pal who shares their grid has me feeling like the biggest dum dum ever. It turns out my way of fanning is to know who plays on the team that I root for, and not pay attention to either where they came from or where they go. So finding an intersection of two teams is SUPER HARD. Even when my team is one on the grid! So I have not bothered to actually click and legitimately play.

Expand full comment
Andrew Blake's avatar

The reason the Cards can't stay the course is because there are no FA options that they will consider affordable and will also measurably improve their starting rotation for next year. Meaning they need to trade value for some controllable and effective young pitching (Luzardo is on my wishlist).

As is, without re-signing Montgomery and Flaherty they don't even have enough pitching right now to reasonably patch together a terrible rotation for 2024.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Andrew Blake's avatar

Yeah I was typing fast and couldn't clarify well but I definitely think of Luzardo as a winter pursuit. The only way they'd be able to get anyone near that caliber at the deadline is if they find one team who wants everything they're selling (Monty/Flaherty/Hicks/Stratton/O'Neill) and has an MLB-ready AAA guy they don't need this year (e.g. someone like Painter before his injury, or Mick Abel).

Agree with everything you said.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Andrew Blake's avatar

Yeah it is insane, and malpractice, that even three of Burleson/Yepez/Gomez/O'Neill were still in this organization as of March, let alone all 4 (and I'd say it should only have been two).

Expand full comment
Lang's avatar

Finding out that Mike Cameron plays Immaculate Grid and used himself for an answer the other day brings me immeasurable joy. Like, of course, why wouldn't you use yourself as an answer if you could?

Expand full comment
dlf's avatar

As an alum of the school in Tuscaloosa, I can say that at least the dumb gambling scandal in baseball was less destructive than the dumb murder in basketball. Hurray for the better sport?

Expand full comment
Sean's avatar

There’s a hockey version of Immaculate Grid that’s the new hotness right now called Puckdoku.

Expand full comment
pasta's avatar

The hockey one makes me feel better about how I'll look at baseball results and wonder, "who the heck is that guy?!" - then I look it up and he's a hall of famer. Hockey is clearly the sport where I know the George Hainsworth's and the Tiny Thompson's, as opposed to wondering who "Luis Aparicio" is

Expand full comment
aboutamoo's avatar

I'll give it a try. I know the names of at least nine hockey players.

Expand full comment
Thomas's avatar

Craig: Following your instructions re: your All-Star sales event, I converted my monthly subscription to an annual subscription. Substack still charged me the regular annual subscription price. Is it possible that you’re having a sale, but Substack isn’t? Can you please have Substack address this?

Expand full comment
NB3131's avatar

Just when you thought the betting industry couldn’t get any worse….

https://nypost.com/2023/07/13/when-betting-on-the-special-olympics-goes-horribly-wrong/

Expand full comment
SamLub's avatar

Yikes. Not sure who’s worse here: the sportsbook or the bettors

Expand full comment
Palmer's avatar

For my first comment as a new subscriber, I'd like to let everybody know that if you're a hockey fan (I assume there are some here), you can play their version of Immaculate Grid at puckdoku.com

Today was the worst I've done on Immaculate Grid, which makes me feel bad, but also I regularly have half my answers from the 80s and 90s, which makes me feel worse.

Expand full comment
DMCj's avatar

Welcome!

Expand full comment
Craig Calcaterra's avatar

Welcome!

Expand full comment
Wes's avatar

Welcome Palmer!

Expand full comment
Miles Goosens's avatar

Maybe this got pointed out yesterday, but the sad, dramatic, slowed-down pop song thing is also a staple of romance reality shows such as Love Island and Temptation Island. There’s a cottage industry of artists who crank these out expressly for TV/movie use.

Example:

https://youtu.be/gCITO54mzQU

Expand full comment
Carl Schlichting's avatar

Vanilla Fudge did it in the 60s - they took the poppy Supremes song, “You Keep Me Hanging On”, and gave it the tone it deserved. https://youtu.be/m4ylSesfe1U

Another notable - Chris Cornell’s version of “Billie Jean”. https://youtu.be/R0uWF-37DAM

Expand full comment
DMCj's avatar

I LOVE that Cornell version. The guitar solo alone is worth the price of admission.

Submitted for your consideration: I Would Die 4 U covered by Noah Guthrie.

Expand full comment
Wes's avatar

Chris Cornell absolutely kills GNR's Patience and Sinead O'Connor's Nothing Compares to You. The dude was a genius. Sad.

Expand full comment
Owen Ranger's avatar

"We're gonna clean that up." Every time I hear Gerrit Cole speak I like him more and more. Sucks that he's a Yankee.

Expand full comment
Sam Bass's avatar

Unabridged version of that Cole quote:

https://youtu.be/Qw54CyMwn8w

Expand full comment