Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Palmer's avatar

For my first comment as a new subscriber, I'd like to let everybody know that if you're a hockey fan (I assume there are some here), you can play their version of Immaculate Grid at puckdoku.com

Today was the worst I've done on Immaculate Grid, which makes me feel bad, but also I regularly have half my answers from the 80s and 90s, which makes me feel worse.

Expand full comment
Kevin Flynn's avatar

Manfred is a jerk and I don't like him. But because I like to challenge my own opinions, I decided to figure out why I don't like him.

First off (no offense), he's a lawyer. Nobody likes highly-paid white collar jerks in charge of blue collar work. It gets really annoying when he takes the podium and starts talking about rule changes and how to improve the game, and you can imagine someone like John Kruk walking up to him with half a doughnut in his mouth saying, "Oh yeah? And where did you play your college ball?"

Second, the market manipulation is abusive. You talked a lot about it in Rethinking Fandom, and if you really want to hurt a large number of people you can't do a lot better than moving their sports teams and tearing away the thing they use to bring their diverse community together. Maybe for an encore he could start tearing down churches and deporting zoo animals in the name of ownership profits.

Mostly I think I'm upset at him for not expressing any appreciation for the huge umbrella under which baseball exists and operates, which grants them the ability to ignore normal business practices. Baseball has a congressionally-granted immunity to antitrust laws. The Commissioner's job is supposed to make decisions in the best interest of baseball, but for that commish to make decisions that only favor ownership, at the expense of fans, then it begs the question of what MLB thinks 'baseball' really is. Because if it's just business, and not America's Pastime, then it should operate like all other business does and not have a legal monopoly. /2¢

Expand full comment
124 more comments...

No posts